From Nov 21, 2016 to Nov 19, 2026, the Take profit at 20% rule returned -50% on CCL, against -33% for buying and holding CCL over the same days.
Its worst drop was -84%, against -83% for holding.
The rule made 1 trade, and 0% of them made money.
The rule: Steps out as soon as the position is up 20%, and steps back in after the next close below the 50-day average. Enters when Price (close) is less than SMA(50). Exits at a take profit of 20%.
Run unchanged on 140 large US stocks from a fixed list, the Take profit at 20% rule beat buying and holding on 57 and did not on 83. Its worst drop was smaller than holding's on 82 of them.
Figures as of November 20, 2026. The live ones load with the page.
Other rules on CCL: Golden cross (-37% vs -33% for holding) · RSI pullback (-22% vs -33% for holding) · Bollinger Band reversion (-35% vs -33% for holding) · MACD crossover (316% vs -33% for holding) · Donchian breakout (-8.9% vs -33% for holding) · Trend and momentum (6.5% vs -33% for holding) · 200-day line (9.7% vs -33% for holding) · Golden cross with a 10% stop (-33% vs -33% for holding)
The Take profit at 20% rule on other stocks: RCL (244% vs 286% for holding) · XOM (215% vs 126% for holding) · CVX (126% vs 136% for holding) · COP (326% vs 248% for holding) · SLB (-29% vs -25% for holding) · OXY (-2.1% vs -1.1% for holding) · T (23% vs 24% for holding) · VZ (51% vs 48% for holding)
Each rule is a textbook example, run unchanged over the last ten years of stored daily prices. The rule and buying and holding start with the same cash and pay the same commission and slippage, before taxes. The stocks are a fixed list of large US companies, picked by size and not by how any rule did on them.
Hypothetical results from past prices. They do not reflect real trading, and past results do not predict future results. Nothing here is investment advice.
Data provided by Twelve Data.
Take profit at 20%: every stock · Every rule · Test a rule on any stock · Rexius Finance home